True Bugs
suborder of class “Insects“
1 suborder, 8 families, 41 species
The classification of the insect order Heteroptera is a subject of controversy. It used to be considered an order but is now considered a suborder within the larger order Hemiptera. There are different proposed classifications, with some preferring to include the family Peloridiidae in the suborder Prosorrhyncha, while others retain it as the suborder Coleorrhyncha. Another option is to place Coleorrhyncha within Heteroptera. The use of the name Heteroptera itself is also debated due to its violation of naming conventions.
Hierarchy
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 2 species
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 4 species
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 6 species
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 2 species
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 38 species
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 2 species
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 6 species
family of suborder “True Bugs“
1 family, 22 species
Classification#
The use of the name “Heteroptera” has had the rank of order, dating back to 1810 by Pierre André Latreille. Only recently has it been relegated to a subsidiary rank within a larger definition of Hemiptera, so many reference works still include it as an order. Whether to continue treating it as a suborder is still a subject of some controversy, as is whether the name itself should ever be used, although three basic approaches ranging from abolishing it entirely to maintaining the taxonomy with a slight change in systematics is proposed, two of which (but not the traditional one) agree with the phylogeny. The competing classifications call for a preference for two suborders versus one when the “living fossil” family Peloridiidae is taken into consideration: In one revised classification proposed in 1995, the name of the suborder is Prosorrhyncha, and Heteroptera is a rankless subgroup within it. The only difference between Heteroptera and Prosorrhyncha is that the latter includes the family Peloridiidae, which is a tiny relictual group that is in its own monotypic superfamily and infraorder. In other words, the Heteroptera and Prosorrhyncha sensu Sorensen et al. are identical except that Prosorrhyncha contains one additional infraorder, called Peloridiomorpha (comprising only 13 small genera). The ongoing conflict between traditional, Linnaean classifications and nontraditional classifications is exemplified by the problem inherent in continued usage of the name Heteroptera when it no longer can be matched to any standard Linnaean rank (as it falls below suborder but above infraorder). If this classification succeeds, then the “Heteroptera” grouping may be discarded, but in that case it is likely that no ranks will be used at all according to the standards of phylogenetic nomenclature. In the traditional classification, the Peloridiidae are retained as their own suborder, called Coleorrhyncha; “Heteroptera” is treated the same. Functionally, the only difference between this classification and the preceding is that the former uses the name Prosorrhyncha to refer to a particular clade, while the traditional approach divides this into the paraphyletic Heteroptera and the monophyletic Coleorrhyncha. Many believe it is preferable to use only one name because the characteristics of the two traditional suborders are too closely related to be treated as separate. Alternatively, the modified approach of placing Coleorrhyncha ‘within’ the Heteroptera can be used. Indeed, as that solution preserves the well-known Heteroptera at the taxonomic rank they traditionally hold while making them a good monophyletic group, it seems preferable to the paraphyletic “Heteroptera” used in older works. In that case, the “core” Heteroptera could be considered a section – as yet unnamed, mainly because the Prosorrhyncha were proposed earlier – within the “expanded” Heteroptera, or the latter could simply be described as consisting of a basal “living fossil” lineage and a more apomorphic main radiation. Whether the name “Coleorrhyncha” is to be retained for the basal lineage or whether the more consistent “Peloridiomorpha” is used instead is a matter of taste, as described below. Separate from the question of the actual “closeness” of Heteroptera and Coleorrhyncha is the potential disruption to traditional construction of names; there seems to be reluctance among hemipterists to abandon the use of “Heteroptera”. This can be seen by the name itself, as it is a violation of convention to use the ending “-ptera” for any rank above genus other than an order – though since it is a convention rather than a mandatory rule of Linnean nomenclature, taxonomists are technically free to violate it (which is why, for example, not all insect orders end in “-ptera”, e.g., Odonata). However, in most cases when such conventions are violated, it does not create an internal conflict as in the present case (that is, the order Hemiptera has a suborder named Heteroptera, which is an internal conflict). At least some hemipterists argue that the name Heteroptera should be dropped entirely to eliminate this internal conflict, though the third possibility offers a workaround. In that case, to achieve full consistency of names “Coleorrhyncha” would probably be dropped in favor of “Peloridiomorpha”.
Further reading#
China, W.E.; Miller, N.C.E. (1959). “Check-list and keys to the families and subfamilies of the Hemiptera-Heteroptera”. Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History), Entomology. London: British Museum. 8 (1): 1–45.
External links#
Heteropteran Systematics Lab at University of California, Riverside http://heteroptera.ucr.edu Identification guide to UK Hemiptera Bugs – Hemiptera
The classification of the insect order Heteroptera is a subject of controversy. It used to be considered an order but is now considered a suborder within the larger order Hemiptera. There are different proposed classifications, with some preferring to include the family Peloridiidae in the suborder Prosorrhyncha, while others retain it as the suborder Coleorrhyncha. Another option is to place Coleorrhyncha within Heteroptera. The use of the name Heteroptera itself is also debated due to its violation of naming conventions.
Ancestry Graph
Further Information
Copyright
